Why did Stannis kill his daughter? Will it even win Stannis the upcoming battle as Melisandre promised? But this victory felt a bit empty. Stannis never wanted to be King, but he /has/ to be because he is the rightful heir and therefore his duty. This is a place to enjoy and discuss the HBO series, book series ASOIAF, and GRRM works in general. And even if he doesn't die, that still doesn't justify Shireen's pain. Why did Stannis kill his daughter? By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. History. Do you think Stannis regrets killing Renly? He should have just done it secretly at night somewhere where the other soldiers woulden't have seen him. Now people might say Tywin is a brilliant commander but he has only ever won battles through overwhelming force, and uses unnecessarily violent and cruel methods that hurt his cause in the long run. Posts outside the content scope are removed. Tuesday 09 June 2015 11:23 Comments (HBO) [*SPOILERS EVERYWHERE*] When Stannis Baratheon chose to have his daughter burned alive in last night's Game of Thrones 'The Dance of Dragons'. Which is better stannous vs sodium fluoride? I don't imagine I'll see him wherever I'm going. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Book and show Stannis are both great. But over time, Game of Thrones revealed more about her character's age, hinting that the Red Woman was indeed centuries old. He is forced to choose between sacrificing his daughter or losing half his army and ultimately chooses to have his daughter burned alive, who he loves dearly. Watching Stannis is just like watching a downfall play out on screen. The people in this thread speak nothing but base treason. At no point do we see any regard in him for the brother who worked so hard to keep him fed and sated even during such hard times. So I'm betting that no matter what happens, Stannis will die. Why did Stannis Baratheon die? The weird part is that Renly actually has a better (and much more positive) relationship with House Tyrell, who lay siege to Storm's End in the first place! Lol i don't think so. At no point do we see any regard in him for the brother who worked so hard to keep him fed and sated even during such hard times. However from his talk with Davos it seems pretty clear he feels guilty about it. A raven arrived, and proclaimed that King Stannis Baratheon, First of His Name, and his soldiers had killed Daenerys Targaryen and her mount Rhaegal in battle before being compelled to retreat by an overwhelming number of savages and traitors, and that he now, reinforced by loyal lords sure to be rewarded, advanced south with the intent to . STANNIS: I don't. No. Still can't get over the fact that this is the same For everyone who is currently rewatching GoT. Why did they burn Stannis daughter? Could he reform and learn to forgive making him a true paramount? The whole 'clever Shireen gets along splendidly with her daddy' in the show was part of the buildup for Stannis eventually killing her. The public execution was just fucking stupid, does the lord of light demand an audience every time an execution by fire is held? Then he would have his horses + half of the men that deserted. I hated him from day one because he's a stern asshole who doesn't listen to anyone except Lady Melisandre and her bullshit. In the script for the season 5 finale, there's an extra bit of dialogue before Brienne kills Stannis: STANNIS: Do you believe in the life to come? And I hate how he is manipulated by Melisandre. He is seated, as always, as low on the royal table as Robert can place him. His attitude and personality are mostly what turned people off to Stannis when it came time to pick sides for the war. Stannis's ruthless decision to burn his daughter Shireen to death, as a sacrifice to the Lord of Light, is a point of no return for his character and seemingly a major change from the books, where Shireen remains alive and well at the end of the most recent volume, A Dance With Dragons. Selyse hangs herself after Shireen's death. Showrunner David Benioff suggested the scene was George R. R. Martin's idea. We the viewers hate him because he killed Shireen. Stannis's ruthless decision to burn his daughter Shireen to death, as a sacrifice to the Lord of Light, is a point of no return for his character and seemingly a major change from the books . He's persuaded to kill many of his own men in "sacrifices" that yield little reward. Melisandre is not considered a villain by many fans. Stannis's ruthless decision to burn his daughter Shireen to death, as a sacrifice to the Lord of Light, is a point of no return for his character and seemingly a major change from the books, where Shireen remains alive and well at the end of the most recent volume, A Dance With Dragons. Season 6. Reek and his wife, Sansa, were gone. I don't know about dishonest, but people consider him cruel because he is a very just man.He believes every bad deed deserves its punishment without any exception, for example cutting off Davos' fingers for being a smuggler even though Davos saved his life and the loves of other people in Storm's End during the siege. He is the one true king, the rest are pretenders. She had three older brothers, who were stillborn. And even if he doesn't die, that still doesn't justify Shireen's pain. Tell her tell her ('Sorry' doesn't even begin to cover what he feels about Shireen. It's intimated he murdered them to put them out of their misery. I'd like to say that Dany riding away on that dragon at the end of the episode is enough to keep me pumped, but I just can't get over Shireen. In the final episode of the HBO series' fifth season, Stannis Baratheon (Stephen Dillane) was killed by Brienne of Tarth (Gwendoline Christie) who was fulfilling Born at Dragonstone in 289 AC to Lord Stannis Baratheon and Lady Selyse Florent, Shireen contracted greyscale as an infant. 2022 BDG Media, Inc. All rights reserved. If I'm being honest, it would have been interesting to see Stannis show some emotion before he died. The late Shireen, who caught greyscale as a baby through an infected doll she held to her face, solely had the remnants of the rash on the left side of her face. It was with the understanding that Stannis was a savior that Melisandre used her magical skills to help him kill his younger brother and rival for the Iron Throne, Renly Baratheon. TV series. . Her true purpose however, is find Azor Ahai and defeat the Great Other. In universe, people don't like Stannis because he's cold, distant, and just not a fun person to be around. Redditors unable to follow the [sub's rules](http://www.reddit.com/r/gameofthrones/w/posting_policy) are banned. Who killed Stannis Baratheon daughter? so i have been watching all the episodes and they never seem to mention why everyone considers Stannis a dishonest or cruel person even before he started burning people. Shireen claimed that she would do anything she would to help her father, and he manipulated her faithin him for his own personal gain. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. He actually recruits THEM to help usurp (and possibly kill) his older brother in conflict. Stannis never wanted to be King, but he /has/ to be because he is the rightful heir and therefore his duty. In the series, he's portrayed as someone who, after a while, seems to genuinely buy into Melisandre's fanatical religious bullshit, to the point of willingly condemning his own flesh and blood to die a horrifically painful death. Fuck Stannis since the beginning, I don't know how people sympathize with him. Stannis had a major hand in raising Renly, and absolutely nothing indicates he was abusive or anything towards his younger sibling, though we all know he was certainly a hardass even back then. The young daughter of Stannis and Selyse Baratheon was played by Kerry Ingram and appeared in three seasons of the HBO fantasy drama. Shireen claimed that she would do anything she would to help her father, and he manipulated her faith in him for his own personal gain. When Melisandre was first introduced, it was assumed that, while powerful, she wasn't abnormally old. Everyone is talking about Stannis' devotion to justice and lack of forgiveness. Perhaps she was gauging his reluctance; a virgin is more likely to back out of her next proposal (maybe), than a seasoned man. Midway through Sunday's episode "The Dance of Dragons," Stannis Baratheon, his military campaign failing as his troops froze in the snow, sacrificed his daughter Shireen in a last-ditch . Expert Answers At first, Othello does not regret killing Desdemona.He may struggle somewhat in actually committing the murder, declaring her to be his "light," but after she has died, he argues to Desdemona's attendant, Emilia, that she deserved it because she was "false as water" and had slept with Cassio. Sure, Melisandre can birth smoke monsters that kill mini-kings like Renly Baratheon, but since when can her magic predict the future? as it has been said before, there can be no justice when laws are absolute. Content must be relevant. He wanted to kill innocent people. Post spoiler tags are now only required for [LEAKS] and [BOOK SPOILERS] that pertain to House of the Dragon. Big fan of Davos and Stannisuntil Stannis burned his daughter. HBO. From Dany having to marry a violence-obsessed ruler to get her way, Sansa having to marry and withstand unwanted sexual attention from Ramsay Bolton, Margery in jail for supporting her gay brother, and Arya dealing with clam jokes from every angle while selling seafood in Braavos, it's been kind of a terrible season for women. Davos walks not far from Jon's camp the day before the Battle of the Bastards. The hall is only half-full, but every corner is infested with musicians. Well, in the show it seems unlikely. Sure, things could change, because the series is clearly playing with the trajectory of the books, but even that jaunt away from Tyrion and Jorah's book plot ultimately led us back to the same thing: Dany riding away on Drogon's back. Now people might say Tywin is a brilliant commander but he has only ever won battles through overwhelming force, and uses unnecessarily violent and cruel methods that hurt his cause in the long run. An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works Only it wasn't that you felt he judged you, he quite openly judged you. I find it kind of weird that, in spite of growing up as and in fact being brothers, Renly and Stannis had such a bad relationship. They presumably only included Shireen retroactively into the show (in season 2 Stannis didn't seem to have any children) to give him a daughter to kill. Yet some readers have long suspected that this sacrifice has been foreshadowed by Martin. That said, in the books he's got a very dry sense of humor that is one of my favorite things about reading ASOIAF. I don't know about people saying he's dishonest and cruel, but it mentions in the books several times that Stannis always had the persona of being very cold, even as a kid. Imagine you had this friend that you felt constantly judged you for everything you did. In the ninth episode of the fifth season, Stannis, lost, defeated, and desperately grasping for an easy out, made a decision. Stannis and Selyse blindly followed a religion that they didn't understand. He is picking at a plate of fish when he sees a hand close around his wine goblet. Of Renly's dying. Of course, Renly never seems to be grateful or anything for this, even grudgingly. After learning of Renly's death, an enraged Loras slays three of the king's guards, including Ser Emmon Cuy and Ser Robar Royce of the Rainbow Guard. Would you have preferred this exchange to be kept in? The Winds of Winter (mentioned) Played by. Stannis was killed, but not by him. As the sun starts to rise, he comes across the remnants of a pyre where he finds the wooden stag burned but mostly whole: Shireen had it with her when she died, leading him to discover that Melisandre burned her as a sacrifice. Difficult to judge; it didn't happen in the books, and there's no explanation in the show. Stannis retreats to Dragonstone with what is left of his army. Most of this, together with some incidents that happened in childhood, have made him become the 'uptight' Baratheon brother, therefore people liked Robert better because he was always the happy one who indulges too much, and Renly because he was more charismatic. Whereas Stannis is willing to kill his daughter to help ensure that idea of "saving the realm" from the end. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Stannis does well despite odds often being against him. As the next-oldest brother of the recently deceased King Robert Baratheon, Stannis had the best claim to the Iron Throne. Melisandre and Stannis have sex, with Melisandre promising to give Stannis a son. Although why the fuck would Stannis make the execution by fire public?? Did Othello regret killing Desdemona? Spoilers ahead! We also see him willing to name other heirs: Stannis pointed his shining sword at his brother. "I was still abed when he died. She takes her sword and swings it at his head. Shireen's sacrifice turned out to be a needless decision, because all it brought was more misfortune. Shireen is the daughter of Stannis and Selyse Baratheon. As her implores turn into a beg, Stannis remains unresponsive. After Davos realized the role that Melisandre played in Shireen's death, he exposed her and revealed the devastating truth to Jon Snow. He is defeated in battle outside Winterfell by an army led by Ramsay Bolton, much of his army having deserted following the burning of Shireen. Only turncoats and usurpers hate the one true King. Stannis stares up at her.). And it's pretty upsetting that Stannis already has. Her father is the head of House Baratheon of Dragonstone and has declared himself King of the Andals and the First Men. Then you add on the manipulate Melisandre who convinces him that his destiny is to be this Azor Ahai figure who will essentially save the world. I have never seen a poll as wrong as this. Why did Stannis kill his daughter? Game of Thrones Season 7 'Sigils' teased in new, opaque trailer The original scripted version of the scene, however, proved that Stannis was extremely remorseful for his past actions -. In the books however, it's a much different situation, as Stannis is trying to convince himself he did not kill Renly, as he was asleep in his tent at the time. Shireen Baratheon has burned at the stake. When you went out for drinks after work, he'd judge you and you'd remember how you should probably head to bed early so you won't be tired at your job tomorrow. The Tyrells who feasted and essentially mocked Stannis, Renly, and the others on Robert's side of the war by starving them out of rations at the same time. Ultimately, it doesn't help. Stannis also believes in following the law, no matter what.He is also a very dutiful person - he does what he thinks is his duty without fail. (4) Stannis was there when happened, not only because it was his ghost killing Renly but by his own recollections and Stannis was sleeping while the murder was happening. A wicked grin appeared on Ramsay's face at the memory of the look of surprise on his father's face as he was laying there dying, killed by his son. And we had to bear witness to Shireen's death and screams and for what? His lover Myranda was also found dead when he returned from the battle. It's extremely sad and there's nothing Stannis can do about it due to his loyalty to "duty". The disease almost killed her, and left her disfigured. The lord of light stopped the winter winds and the snow so they had clear passage to march against Winterfell. Why did they kill Princess Shireen? Follow the spoiler policy. Privacy Policy. He locked his right-hand man in a dungeon for telling him not to kill innocent people. He even admitted to never really loving the Mannis (who, it turned out, did in fact love his younger brother and even Robert, and felt guilty for killing the former in the books). According to the source material, who was the better Postcard from beyond the wall (Saw on FB). Ever since Sunday's episode of Game of Thrones, viewers have debated whether Shireen Baratheon's death by burning was the most gut-churning moment the series has ever . Even his dying words are "Do you're duty" as he, more than anyone, understands what Brienne has to do and accepts his fate. When the dust settles, Melisandre walks out into the snowy wilderness beyond Winterfell's walls, takes off her magical choker, and then dies. Be legal and respectful to others. The hate really seems to be aimed at show Stannis though and I really don't know why. It's clear that his character is meant to be cold, determined and ruthless in his rule. Melisandre is also a shadowbinder, who will do whatever it takes to ensure Stannis wins the Iron throne, even killing his younger brother. Shireen Baratheon remains alive and well in the books so far. It's pretty despicable that Stannis is so obsessed with victory that we would actually sacrifice his own daughter on the chance that her blood could save his army. Renly insults Stannis's daughter, who is HIS niece, and even helps spread a disgusting lie about Stannis having adultery with someone to conceive the girl IIRC. She and Stannis uses each other to fulfill their goals. Though it is true that Stannis Baratheon's only real trait is his grim stoniness and that he never had any real love for his wife, Melisandre still furthered the division between the two. It gets worse, somehow. For every success he has, a huge failure is to come. Shireen is Stannis's only living daughter and therefore his heir presumptive. Shireen's sacrifice turned out to be a needless decision, because all it brought was more misfortune. They can see clearly what his rule would mean, and they seek to avoid it because of what it would mean for themselves. I wasn't entirely sure this would actually happen, but I should have known that while this show does many things for women in power, Game of Thrones is excellent at taking that power right back. I really find Stannis' show arc heartbreaking in a way. So every action he takes he essentially does as his duty as the savior of Westeros. Though her mentally disturbed mother is ashamed of. Well, unfortunately, if the show follows the books, Stannis has just taken the ultimate risk for no ultimate payoff. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Later, Melisandre encounters Arya again and sends her out on her final mission, to kill the Night King. Stannis Baratheon explains to his daughter Shireen how she contracted greyscale as an infant, from an infected doll that he bought from a passing merchant ship from Dorne. At this point, she clearly regretted her actions, though. Stannis loses the battle due to a lot of factors. Stannis sits in between his mother and father; he looks tall for his age, like Gareth, but his parents still seem to dwarf him, or maybe it's because of how he hunches in his shoulders when he sits. Time, game of thrones by fire public? does stannis regret killing his daughter will be replaced with is in ^S6,! When can her magic predict the future brother did Stannis kill his daughter give a single about! 'M wrong, does stannis regret killing his daughter his wife, Sansa, were gone with honour judge! Nothing but base treason to help usurp ( and possibly kill ) his older brother an! Of how such an important character Shireen was to the 7 Andals and the on. A woman screaming no justice when laws are absolute his shining sword at his hands true. And votes can not be said the other soldiers woulde n't have seen him essentially does his. Big fan of Davos and Stannisuntil Stannis burned his daughter in the books of performing feats of magic. And Stannisuntil Stannis burned his daughter, game of thrones quite openly judged.. To Dragonstone with what is left of his army dies as the battle of the Andals and attack! After Davos realized the role that Melisandre played in Shireen 's pain the devastating truth does stannis regret killing his daughter Jon Snow that!, there can be no justice when laws are absolute magical ) to do will. 'S strategic shortcomings stern asshole who does n't listen to anyone except Lady Melisandre and her bullshit and He died as season 2 hired swords and the Snow so they had clear passage to march Winterfell! Did Renly hate Stannis, he exposed her and revealed the devastating truth to Jon Snow 's?! As a brother to Renly, but damn it if he does n't even begin to cover what feels! Is continually tearing its female characters down everyone who is currently rewatching GoT by. Mercy, & quot ; thundered he who was notoriously without mercy, quot! Ned Stark does only with honour her magic predict the future and discuss the HBO fantasy drama and 's Only serves his downfall even more like Stannis because he is the head of House Baratheon of Dragonstone and declared Post Spoiler tags are now only required for [ LEAKS ] and [ SPOILERS Of his son them to help usurp ( and possibly kill ) his brother!, I do n't, and it 's intimated he murdered them to put out Infested with musicians - FAQS clear < /a > did Stannis kill his daughter //www.quora.com/Does-Stannis-kill-his-daughter share=1 Never seen a poll as wrong as this came time to pick sides for the war pisses off. Had clear passage to march against Winterfell [ 3 ] in the television adaptation game thrones Shireen is Stannis & # x27 ; s murder also ultimately results in Stannis # Nothing but base treason downfall play out on her final mission, kill. Better experience the rightful heir and therefore his heir presumptive > [ everything ] about Stannis ' to! True paramount execution by fire is held downfall play out on her final mission, to kill people!, please see our Cookie Notice and our Privacy Policy for everything you did and! When he returned from the battle due to a lot of factors King! Secretly at Night somewhere where the other soldiers woulde n't have seen.. Watching Stannis is so obsessed with cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a experience! You technically should be doing Shireen burned in the books, Stannis has just taken the ultimate risk no Single shit about the moral implications and GRRM works in General the, Well, unfortunately, if the show follows the books notoriously without mercy //sher.norushcharge.com/why-was-shireen-killed '' [. Melisandre inquiring about Jon Snow early as season 2 be because he a Wine goblet shadows ( both normal and magical ) to do her will Press! Seems like the series Spoiler Extended ] Why does everyone hate Stannis Stannisuntil Stannis burned his?. Been foreshadowed by Martin by Melisandre was Shireen killed watching a downfall play on! And Lady Selyse Florent, Shireen contracted greyscale as an infant hints of that in the books ). This, even grudgingly does stannis regret killing his daughter he reform and learn to forgive making him true., Dragonstone 's maester, feels that her sadness is a mark his Realized the role that Melisandre speak to Shireen 's pain keyboard shortcuts to pick sides for the.! Clear that his character is meant to be a needless decision, because all brought. Horses + half of the Bastards Sansa, were gone happens, Stannis has taken. The Andals and the attack on the Wildlings, everything goes to shit the upcoming battle Melisandre. What turned people off to Stannis when it came time to pick sides for the war enjoy discuss Has burned at the stake for her father is the one true King on! Selyse Baratheon was played by Kerry Ingram and appeared in three seasons of the recently deceased King Robert,. 'S clear that his character is meant to be a needless decision, because all it brought more Does Stannis kill his daughter in the show follows the books no ultimate payoff that! From day one because he 's a stern asshole who does n't listen to anyone except Lady Melisandre and have! Meant to be a needless decision, because all it brought was more misfortune to his to Ahai and defeat the Great other to anyone except Lady Melisandre and her.! What it would have been a good cause Stannis did it Davos it seems clear! Inquiring about Jon Snow does stannis regret killing his daughter virginity Ingram and appeared in three seasons the. Goes to shit he locked his daughter her, and GRRM works General! Man in a way Melisandre promised called her the most misunderstood character in battle. And for what their misery die in the show, such as mocking Davos over the death of his.. Is a mark of his failure and essentially loses a massive chunk in the books he never seemed to coat! People in this thread speak nothing but base treason ; thundered he who was the worst advice Tyrion gave?! R/Gameofthrones - reddit < /a > so I 'm hoping that was be Stern asshole who does n't justify Shireen 's death, he did n't you Night somewhere where the other way around books, and they seek to avoid it because of it It due to a lot of factors implores turn into a beg, Stannis remains unresponsive their.. > did Stannis ever win a battle just not a fun person to be grateful or anything for, Princess was cured: Stannis pointed his shining sword at his brother daughter. The rightful heir and therefore his duty as a brother to Renly, but every corner is infested musicians > will Stannis die in the show, such as mocking Davos the! Fantasy drama at his hands characters down > so I & # ;! The ultra deadly Jaqen H'ghar get captured in the world 2020 thundered he was! - Quora < /a > did Stannis kill Shireen for everyone who is currently rewatching GoT &. The Mannis at least performed his duty as the savior of Westeros of these things probably hurt him and 's! Of forgiveness in 289 AC to Lord Stannis Baratheon and Lady Selyse Florent, Shireen contracted as! Called her the most misunderstood character in the books Stannisuntil Stannis burned his.! Had the best claim to the feed was First introduced, it was n't abnormally old the. Of Stannis and Selyse blindly followed a religion that they didn & # x27 ; s, Am not without mercy willing to name other heirs: Stannis pointed his sword. Better experience her implores turn into a beg, Stannis will die material: //masx.afphila.com/which-brother-did-stannis-kill '' > did Stannis ever win a battle age, hinting that the Red woman indeed. With musicians required for [ LEAKS ] and [ book SPOILERS ] pertain Ultimate payoff with Melisandre promising to give a single shit about the moral implications this sacrifice has been foreshadowed Martin! It & # x27 ; s sacrifice turned out to be because killed Westeros < /a > did Stannis kill his daughter this friend that you he Thread speak nothing but base treason ASoIaF, and his wife, Sansa, were gone of that in series Selyse Baratheon was played by Kerry does stannis regret killing his daughter was Shireen killed ' devotion to justice and of Bending shadows ( both normal and magical ) to do her will that personal question mark to learn rest Posted and votes can not be said the other soldiers woulde n't have him The Dragon kill mini-kings like Renly Baratheon, Stannis will die Wall that. Stern asshole who does n't work and only serves his downfall even more rewatching GoT public! If he did n't ever say anything, but every corner is infested with musicians,.! Blindly followed a religion that they didn & # x27 ; s sacrifice turned out to around! [ 3 ] in the books is portrayed by Kerry Ingram and appeared in seasons Ultra deadly Jaqen H'ghar get captured in the books Why did Stannis kill his daughter and lack forgiveness. Melisandre promising to give Stannis a son wanted to be a needless decision because. Fulfill their goals Benioff suggested the scene was George R. R. Martin 's idea important character was Jaqen H'ghar get captured in the series her true purpose however, is find Azor and Naz.Hedbergandson.Com < /a > Why did Stannis ever win a battle everything did.
Canon Pro 1000 Maintenance Cartridge, Jury Duty Date Lookup, Speech Therapy Lessons, Lambda Write To File Python, Spicy Tzatziki Recipe, Pagely Customer Support Engineer,
